Vital Football

Latest Charlton Athletic News

It was Wrong to Block ZZ Call-up?

It was Wrong to Block ZZ Call-up?

Usually I do not actually focus specifically on a single poll when the results are revealed, but the one surrounding the Addicks refusal to release Zheng Zhi for international duty later this month had caught my eye.

China has wanted him to play in two international matches later this month, however as these games were outside of the designated international window the Addicks have refused to let him play, something which they are quite entitled to do so under the current rules of the game set down by FIFA.

It was quite an even split with 30% both saying Yes the Addicks were right to block this and they could see both sides of the argument. However, the majority ruled and 40% thought the Addicks were wrong because it is his country.

Even though I might not agree with the final outcome of the poll I can see all sides of this argument, and as such I can see how it could have gone anyway but the defining factor is that FIFA set out designated windows in which international matches are scheduled to be played within, so to refuse a player within this window would be well out of order (and wouldn't be allowed) however with the Football Associations, or Federations as some are of all countries knowing this, if their matches fall outside of this window they can have little argument.

In all fairness to the Chinese Football Federation (or Association) they have not argued this, but as this is something that I feel strongly on, and do think that the Addicks were well within their rights to block such a move for Zheng Zhi I felt I had to say a little more on this matter than just accept what that recent poll showed.

What is the thought among the Addicks followers on this site on this issue? Am I just talking rubbish, or do I make sense? Share these feelings below so we can discuss them.

It's easy to register, simply click the link and start getting involved by having your say on this great club.



Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Join the Vital Fantasy Football League - its Free!

Writer:Charlton Addickt
Date:Monday October 15 2007
Time: 8:42PM

Comments

0
I really do feel that voting for the Addicks being wrong on this matter was wrong, as I think my argument above backs up
Charlton Addickt
15/10/2007 20:45:00
0
Well I voted for seeing both sides! It's a hard one isn't it. The selfish part of me is glad that he's not going, but another side of me is thinking it's slightly unfair to China. But your argument is fair sir and may have swayed me :)
Pardew is Sexy
15/10/2007 23:08:00
Page 1/1
  1. 1

Login to post a comment

Best of Vital Network

Vital Boxing - Brook Not on the Slide

Recent Charlton Athletic Articles

The Valley That Once Was

The Valley could be restored to its former glory.

FA Boosts Cheating Powers for 2017/18

The Football Association announced earlier today that they have extended their powers when it comes to punishing retrospective simulation.

Charlton Release Five - Friendlies Confirmed

Charlton Athletic confirmed this week that five players would be released when their contracts expired this summer.

Five gone: Have we signed anyone worthwhile?

We are slow to bring in Players again!

Archived Vital Charlton Articles

Vital Charlton articles from

Site Journalists

Kieran Keogh
no email
Profile
Michael Tucker
no email
Profile

Current Poll (see more polls)

Swindon MotM
Suggested By:
Rudd7%
Solly2%
Bauer0%
Pearce2%
Dasilva10%
Holmes58%
Forster-Caskey7%
Jackson2%
Crofts2%
Byrne5%
Magennis5%
Sub-Ahearne-Grant0%
Sub-Aribo0%
Sub-Barnes0%
ScoopDragon Publishing Entire League Network of Sites

League Table

# Team P W D L Pts. GD
C Sheff Utd 46 30 10 6 100 45
P Bolton 46 25 11 10 86 32
3 Scunthorpe 46 24 10 12 82 26
4 Fleetwood 46 23 13 10 82 21
5 Bradford 46 20 19 7 79 19
6 Millwall 46 20 13 13 73 9
7 Southend 46 20 12 14 72 17
8 Oxford 46 20 9 17 69 13
9 Rochdale 46 19 12 15 69 9
10 Bristol Rovers 46 18 12 16 66 -2
11 Peterborough 46 17 11 18 62 0
12 MK Dons 46 16 13 17 61 2
13 Charlton 46 14 18 14 60 7
14 Walsall 46 14 16 16 58 -7
15 Wimbledon 46 13 18 15 57 -3
16 Northampton 46 14 11 21 53 -13
17 Oldham 46 12 17 17 53 -13
18 Shrewsbury 46 13 12 21 51 -17
19 Bury 46 13 11 22 50 -12
20 Gillingham 46 12 14 20 50 -20
R Port Vale 46 12 13 21 49 -25
R Swindon 46 11 11 24 44 -22
R Coventry 46 9 12 25 39 -31
R Chesterfield 46 9 10 27 37 -35
The Vital Football Members League
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
Vital Football Comment

Recent Charlton Athletic Results (view all)

Charlton Athletic Fixtures (view all)

Vital Members League Table

RankNamePoints
1.Wilmingtonian2
2.JeromeThomas142
3.TristanWhite1
4.roystalin1
5.mr_snipp19861
6.Meeko1
7.kishy1
8.john west1
9.djandrew1
10.cafc till i die1
Write for Vital Football